Brazilian law graduate, 22, dies following allergic reaction during hospital scan
A routine medical procedure turned fatal for a 22-year-old law graduate, raising urgent questions about contrast media safety.
Leticia Paul, a young woman from Lontras, Brazil, died on Aug. 21, fewer than 24 hours after suffering a severe allergic reaction during a CT scan at Alto Vale Regional Hospital in Rio do Sul, as People reports.
Paul was reportedly undergoing a CT scan on Aug. 20 as part of a routine medical checkup involving the use of a contrast agent, a substance commonly used to enhance imaging results. During the procedure, she experienced anaphylactic shock, a life-threatening allergic reaction that typically results in a sudden decline in vital functions. The episode quickly escalated, leading to emergency intervention.
Johns Hopkins Medicine defines anaphylactic shock as a severe allergic reaction that can lead to airway constriction, throat swelling, and a dramatic drop in blood pressure -- all symptoms that reduce oxygen flow and can rapidly become fatal. According to reports, Paul needed to be intubated after her condition worsened. Despite medical efforts to stabilize her, she died the following day, Aug. 21.
Her death was confirmed by her aunt, Sandra Paul, who also disclosed that Leticia had a previous medical history involving kidney stones. The family has not publicly stated whether she had any known allergies related to contrast agents or similar substances used in medical imaging.
Hospital facing scrutiny
Alto Vale Regional Hospital, where Paul underwent the scan, released a statement through local media affirming that all procedures were conducted in line with current medical standards.
In their words, the hospital maintained its "commitment to ethics, transparency, and healthcare safety" and emphasized adherence to clinical protocols. However, the facility has yet to respond to detailed inquiries from multiple media outlets, including People, as of Aug. 23.
Reactions from the community have been swift. Colégio Sinodal Ruy Barbosa, where Paul attended school prior to university, shared their sympathies in a public statement.
"We express our solidarity with her family and friends, wishing them comfort and strength in this time of grief," the school wrote in a message publicized by Oeste SC Notícias.
Paul was in the early stages of launching a professional life dedicated to legal advocacy. After finishing her law degree, she was actively pursuing postgraduate studies in two specialized tracks: law and real estate. Her academic journey was considered promising by peers and institutions alike.
Memorial services reflect life cut short
The aftermath of her death saw an outpour of grief from both personal and professional communities. As funeral arrangements proceeded, Paul’s body was cremated at the Vatican Crematorium located in Balneário Camboriú, a port city to the southeast known for its tranquil coastline and modern facilities. No further details from the family were made public concerning the service.
Paul's passing has prompted an outcry among those who feel protocols for identifying high-risk patients should be revisited. Critics argue that while contrast agents are commonly used and generally safe, the risks for a minority of recipients remain dangerously underestimated. Although such reactions are rare, the sudden progression of symptoms in cases like Paul’s makes prompt identification and treatment vital.
The National Health Surveillance Agency in Brazil, Anvisa, has not yet made a public statement regarding this specific incident. However, regulated guidance on contrast agents typically includes patient screening, especially concerning allergy history, renal function, and prior adverse reactions to similar substances.
Lessons to learn
1. Know your medical history and disclose it clearly. Before undergoing any diagnostic examination involving injections or contrast materials, patients should provide a complete history -- including known allergies and underlying conditions like kidney problems. Although Leticia Paul’s medical file included past kidney stone episodes, it is unknown if any allergy screening was performed in advance.
2. Understand the substances used during routine tests. CT scans often involve the use of contrast agents that enhance imaging quality, yet not all patients are aware of their content. Asking questions about side effects and potential allergic reactions is a basic but often overlooked safety measure.
3. Emergency readiness can save lives, but it has limits. Anaphylactic shock can develop within minutes, and although intubation and resuscitation can be successful, there are cases where even rapid intervention cannot prevent fatal outcomes. Victims should never be blamed, as even planned procedures can result in unforeseeable complications despite best practices being followed.
Why this story matters
This case underscores the critical importance of patient safety protocols, especially when dealing with even seemingly benign diagnostic tools like contrast CT scans. It calls attention to the need for robust allergen screenings and emergency preparedness in hospitals of all sizes. Leticia Paul’s premature death highlights how complex and dangerous medical reactions can go unnoticed until it’s too late.
Furthermore, this incident should catalyze conversations in the medical community about improving risk communication and consent procedures for patients about to undergo specialized imaging, particularly for younger patients who might assume low risk without clear guidance.