Saturday, May 31, 2025
CRIME NEWS     CRIME ANALYSIS     TRUE CRIME STORIES
/
CRIME NEWS     CRIME ANALYSIS     TRUE CRIME STORIES
/
CRIME NEWS     CRIME ANALYSIS     TRUE CRIME STORIES
/
CRIME NEWS     CRIME ANALYSIS     TRUE CRIME STORIES
/
 May 29, 2025

Body found in Long Island pool tied to detective who helped lead fugitive search

In a bizarre twist of fate, a Suffolk County detective who led the search for a murder suspect made a startling discovery in his own backyard pool. The grim find has left investigators piecing together the final moments of a months-long manhunt.

According to the New York Post, Detective Thomas Corso and his teenage son were preparing their East Shoreham pool for summer when they discovered a well-preserved body floating beneath the winter cover. The body is believed to be that of Matthew Zoll, a 23-year-old murder suspect who disappeared after allegedly killing his father in November.

The location of the discovery holds particular significance, as Corso's property borders a wooded area that leads directly to William Floyd Parkway. This thoroughfare is approximately half a mile from where Zoll reportedly crashed his vehicle and fled on foot after the alleged murder of his father.

Tragic Discovery Unveils Final Path

Suffolk Police Commissioner Kevin Catalina revealed compelling evidence linking the body to the fugitive murder suspect. The clothing, lack of footwear, and proximity to Zoll's last known location strongly suggest the body belongs to the wanted man.

The discovery occurred when Corso and his son were removing the pool's Loop-Loc cover. Investigators noted that a portion of the cover had been tampered with, suggesting someone had deliberately attempted to hide beneath it.

Police believe Zoll may have sought refuge under the pool cover during his escape, leading to his eventual death. The exact cause of death remains unknown, with drowning, hypothermia, and suffocation all being considered as potential factors.

Intensive Manhunt Details Surface

The US Marshals New York/New Jersey Fugitive Task Force, including Detective Corso himself, had conducted an extensive search of the surrounding area. Their efforts focused on the 1,600-acre Brookhaven State Park and nearby wooded regions.

Despite the thorough investigation and deployment of significant resources, the search teams were unable to locate Zoll during the initial manhunt. The discovery in Corso's pool has now provided crucial answers to the months-long mystery.

Law enforcement officials are currently awaiting DNA test results and autopsy findings to definitively confirm the body's identity. These forensic examinations will also help determine the precise cause and timing of death.

Mental Health Connection Emerges

Reports indicate that Zoll suffered from schizophrenia, adding a mental health component to the tragic narrative. The suspect had been wanted for the alleged stabbing death of his 61-year-old father, Joseph Zoll, a postal worker.

The November incident occurred inside their Rocky Point home, prompting an immediate police response and subsequent manhunt. The circumstances surrounding the alleged murder and Zoll's mental state at the time remain under investigation.

Commissioner Catalina has maintained a cautious approach, emphasizing the need for scientific confirmation while acknowledging the strong likelihood that the body belongs to the fugitive.

Why This Story Matters

This case resonates across the Suffolk County and Long Island communities because it highlights vulnerabilities in public safety, mental health awareness, and fugitive recovery strategies. With a homicide suspect seemingly hiding — and dying — in plain sight, law enforcement will face renewed scrutiny over the thoroughness of their search efforts.

Furthermore, the disturbing proximity between detective and suspect will likely prompt discussions around boundaries, confidentiality, and public trust. It underscores the unpredictable nature of crime and the proximity at which danger can quietly exist.

Conclusion

What began as a family tragedy with the alleged murder of 61-year-old Joseph Zoll may now have come to a close with the grim discovery of his son’s body in a detective’s backyard pool. Matthew Zoll had disappeared near William Floyd Parkway in November, and his body remained hidden under a worn portion of a covered pool in East Shoreham, yards away from where he had last been seen. Suffolk County officials are awaiting full forensic results, while the home’s owner, Detective Thomas Corso, who ironically helped lead the manhunt, remains publicly silent.

Related Posts

Written By: Rampart Stonebridge

I'm Rampart Stonebridge, a curious and passionate writer who can't get enough of true crime. As a criminal investigative journalist, I put on my detective hat, delving deep into each case to reveal the hidden truths. My mission? To share engaging stories and shed light on the complexities of our mysterious world, all while satisfying your curiosity about the intriguing realm of true crime.
Copyright © 2025 - U.S. Crime News | All Rights Reserved.
magnifier